Get your PC classics at
Picture of the Week
Tim Cain, master of Fallout and King of the land.
Fallout 4 Responses: What do you think of it?
I'm enjoying it! 23%
I like it, but I have a lot of the same frustrations from Fallout 3 23%
I'm not enjoying the new features/additions 7%
I'm dissatisfied and/or hoping Obsidian gets another shot 46%
Total Votes: 13
The next step in human evolution.

Username: Password:
Log me on automatically each visit
If you haven't already, you can register an account.

Search News Archives
Use the following form to search for news items which match the selected search criteria.
Open Forum: A Challenge
Open Forum: A Challenge [ Community -> Editorial ]
Posted by King of Creation Fri 02 Feb 2007, 7:36 PM
News related to Top Story: Prove Us Wrong

There has been a lot of talk in the last few days (again) about why we, the Fallout community, are so set in our ways. One thing that has been really bothering me while reading comments on various forums has to do with gameplay. Take this for example, a comment made by aries100 on the RPGWatch forums:

To me, clear it is, that NMA basically wants the same gameplay as in FO1 and FO2.
Maybe they will agree to updated graphics, and the use of a PhysX engine in the game, but they still want their turnbased combat and the other things in FO1 and FO2. However, this isn't a realistic approach in today's competetive market.

I don't think this has ever been really addressed. Why, please tell me, is turnbased combat an unrealistic approach in the market? The Fallout series was a commercial success, and Tactics held records for pre-order. Some of the most successful RPG and RPG-esque games in history have had turnbased combat, most notably the Final Fantasy series. You cannot tell me that Final Fantasy was not a commercial success.

So to anyone reading this, I pose this challenge: Prove to me that turn-based combat, or even any other aspect of Fallout gameplay, is not marketable.

I don't want to see baseless claims like this one by aries100. If I (and the rest of the FO community) am to be convinced that turnbased combat is unreasonable, then I need a very convincing argument.

I also encourage any developers that read this, whether from Bethesda or from another company, to add some input to this as well.


There are 129 comments on this article. Click here to comment.

^ Support DAC!
Related news items
News related to Top Story: Prove Us Wrong
  • Open Forum: A Challenge
Last 5 news items under Community -> Editorial
Last 5 news items in the Topic Area: Community
Last 5 news items in the Category: Editorial
Last 5 news items posted by King of Creation
All news items posted on Fri 02 February 2007


Hot Topics
Help Support DAC!
International DAC
Fallout Series
Official sites
Hosted Sites
Our Friends
Site hosted by Sorcerer's Place